Bullock’s vs. Baltimore Oriole: females in winter

Hi there,

Drab first year Baltimore Orioles are an interesting, and daunting, study. In their 1998 paper detailing female Bullock’s vs. female Baltimore Orioles in the journal, Birding, Cin-Ty Lee and Andrew Birch discuss the following: “Many Baltimores seen in winter or late fall have grayish bellies and are exceedingly pale overall in coloration. These birds superficially resemble Bullock’s. Our examinations of female Baltimore specimens collected in Mexico in December and January revealed that such individuals can become exceedingly pale. Many specimens, especially those collected in Mexico, so closely resemble Bullock’s that at first we believed they were mislabeled.”

The white median (upper) and greater (lower) coverts (wing bars) are of note. With Bullock’s the upper edge of the median wing bar is consistently serrated with black “teeth.” The median wing bar on Baltimore generally has a squared-off, not serrated, look lending to a straight-edged appearance. However, there is overlap to this feature and some HY female Baltimore Orioles show a serrated leading edge to the median covert. In his review of Lee and Birch’s new field mark, Jaramillo (1999) reviewed and measured this feature on 19 Baltimore and 54 Bullock’s Orioles. He categorized the tooth-mark serration to the median covert into 4 types. Overlap in this feature occurred most prominently among Type 2 coverts, which show a small, pointed black spur along the top edge of the covert. A total of 36.8 % of the Baltimore and 38.9 % of Bullock’s in his sample showed this feature. There was a small degree of overlap with the large, black tooth serration (the “classic” examples most typically shown on Bullock’s in field guides) associated with Type 3. A total of 15.8 % Baltimore showed a Type 3 pattern with Bullock’s totaling 55.6 % . In their rebuttal, Lee & Birch (2001) stated that the field identifiable aspect of the serrated edge lies in its asymmetric quality, which is derived from the combination of point length (“tooth” serration) and taper (the distance that the white tip extends or tapers up the anterior part of the feather).

Another feature of note w.  Bullock’s is the blending of the median and greater covert bar as of result of the white feather edges extending far up the leading edge of the feathers, producing thin veneers of white (Lee & Birch 1998). The result of this leads to a reduced delineation between the two wings bars and a weak greater covert bar which blends into the area between the two white covert bars. With Baltimore, the effect is two bold, thick white wing bars with the greater covert bar ending more abruptly and having less blending of white extending up the leading edge of the feathers. When that appearance is noted, as is seen on the (undisclosed location) bird, the bird falls out of the Bullock’s camp and into Baltimore or Baltimore x Bullock’s camp.

The Pakenham Bullock’s has a high contrast face w. a light supercilum contrasting with slightly darker crown and a diffuse dark eyeline. The (undisclosed location) bird (HY Baltimore) has a low contrast face, although it does appear to have some fascinating characters such as: darkish smudge to the loral area and a noticeable amount of lemony tones to the throat and upper breast. With these fascinating characters in mind, it is certainly possible to me at this point that this bird could have hailed from the Great Plains where the two reportedly hybridize in a narrow belt in the western region of the ‘Plains (Rising 1970).

12310630_987842311275669_5068309532422743722_n2

Photo: Pakenham Bullock’s Oriole (BUOR).  Many thanks to Tom Devesceri for allowing me to showcase this rather impressive shot of this skulker.

bruce Bullock's Oriole_1J8A7934

Photo: ID comments above. See below for more samples of the (undisclosed location) Baltimore…

DSC_0013[2] DSC_0014[2]DSC_0017[2](1)

Thank you to an anonymous observer, Tom Devesceri and Michelle Martin for use of their photos and thank you for stopping by to have a read!

_________________________________________________________________________

Fallowfield Station Oriole — 26 December 2015

In the middle of a very relaxing n cozy break from hardcore birding, I received a text from a birder: “an oriole at a feeder near where you live; I can pick you up in the morning on my way to see the bird.” I read the text, frowned and thought “absolutely not; I’m on a break…no more, no more…I need rest.” The following morning I went out for a nice morning run. When I arrived home I started to flirt with the idea of ducking out to see the bird. Comfy couch + warm fire + reading + fam. time or “Special Assignment”..? Hmmmm. In the end, somehow, I couldn’t resist: special assignment it was. No rest for the wicked, as they say!

At approximately 1300 h, the oriole visited the feeder for approximately 5 minutes. Lorraine Elworthy and I were able to take many pics of the bird. I wanted to approach this difficult ID this way: call the ID of the bird out while in the field and then carefully review the photos in a quiet study area afterwards to see if I was correct. The feedback one receives while observing a moving target when one is filled to the brim with adrenaline vs. carefully and methodically working on an ID from photos is completely different! Immediately, the bird stood out as a Baltimore, not a Bullock’s. It was bright orangey-yellow where it happened to be well-coloured; had two bold paper-white wing bars atop a jet black wing (high contrast); and a “plain” face, lacking the subtle “cap”, light eyebrow and a dark eyeline commonly seen on similar aged/sexed Bullock’s. It was only upon reviewing the photos did I begin to doubt my ID ever-so-slightly (which always means…just enough to cause trouble!). Quietly, I went back and forth but settled on Baltimore. I took a short break, then went at the ID one last time: Baltimore. However, all this said, it is difficult to eliminate the possibility that this specimen is displaying some level of introgression between Baltimore x Bullock’s  (comment added after further review of pertinent material and discussion with blackbird authorities. Added on 14 January 2016).

Note on the bird the serrated leading edge to the median (upper) covert bar. The nature of these serrations must be examined in order to make a case for Baltimore: they are symmetrical; centered and balanced in the middle of each median covert feather. The end result is the spacing between the “teeth” is quite even throughout. The serrations were cause for concern upon review of the photos but the nature of the serrations and a quick review of the degree of overlap in black “tooth” length as per Alvaro Jaramillo’s review of Lee and Birch’s initial study reminded me that serrations, to some degree, are consistent in both Bullock’s and Baltimore. However, asymmetrical serrations appear to be a Bullock’s trait whereas symmetrical serrations appear to be a Baltimore trait and this bird showed symmetrical serrations. Photos of the bird below…

025 (800x540)

016 (800x575) 020 (800x522)

026 (800x469)

_________________________________________________________________________

References

Dunn, J.L. and J. Alderfer. 2011. National Geographic Field Guide to the Birds of North America. 6th ed. Washington, D.C.: National Geographic Society.

Jaramillo, A, C.T. Lee and A. Birch. 2001. Point/counterpoint: oriole wing covert pattern. Birding 33(1): 61-68.

Lee C.T. and A. Birch. 1998. Field identification of female and immature Bullock’s and Baltimore Orioles. Birding 30: 282-295.

Rising, J.D. 1970. Morphological variation and evolution of some North American orioles. Systematic Zoology 19: 315-351.

Sibley, D.A. 2014. The Sibley Guide to Birds. 2nd ed. New York: Alfred A. Knopf.

_________________________________________________________________________

“Gray-bellied” female Baltimore Orioles (November – December)

https://www.flickr.com/photos/ryser915/5182361640/in/photolist-8TWXyL-8TWXNf-7doaCi-hJWZTc-aM1TLg-5guJBd-6oJiFS-5guJk7-5guJNG-5gqorF-7gubpB-dsuqfy-aSCAGT-5zTwMY-AEZuou-qPkTmm-6qMXVX-A844eu-Bu7mvG-5DbHzk-pn7Wac-sGL76p-8PStM4-riD1se-BvcBEB-rMpFQQ-rkthcD-48WWZn-r9qLWx-qYdG3J-4yN9bL-Bjk1AW-4z7rd8-A3SngM-qfHCB7-q2pvdg-ocpkVc-AC9ptf-BrprQY-Bb9fs1-AERKhX-zHqd5h-Bb9ekG-B6DCze-A5QGst-AVJp2H-4yHRft-Bvdfqb-ormC29-orvNfY

____

https://www.flickr.com/photos/63636922@N05/22532044659/in/photolist-Ak5BSB-zSv8cM-BzY6nQ-AcU1iC-B9W4bi-otouww-owvBRv-qT2fyq-8TTTn4-8TWXEm-8TWXyL-8TWXNf-7doaCi-hJWZTc-aM1TLg-5guJBd-6oJiFS-5guJk7-5guJNG-5gqorF-7gubpB-dsuqfy-aSCAGT-5zTwMY-AEZuou-qPkTmm-6qMXVX-A844eu-Bu7mvG-5DbHzk-pn7Wac-sGL76p-8PStM4-riD1se-BvcBEB-rMpFQQ-rkthcD-48WWZn-r9qLWx-qYdG3J-4yN9bL-Bjk1AW-4z7rd8-A3SngM-qfHCB7-q2pvdg-ocpkVc-AC9ptf-BrprQY-Bb9fs1

____

https://www.flickr.com/photos/lmedlock/22395941794/in/photolist-A844eu-Bu7mvG-5DbHzk-pn7Wac-sGL76p-8PStM4-riD1se-BvcBEB-rMpFQQ-rkthcD-48WWZn-r9qLWx-qYdG3J-4yN9bL-Bjk1AW-4z7rd8-A3SngM-qfHCB7-q2pvdg-ocpkVc-AC9ptf-BrprQY-Bb9fs1-AERKhX-zHqd5h-Bb9ekG-B6DCze-A5QGst-AVJp2H-4yHRft-Bvdfqb-ormC29-orvNfY-ApXSYE-oteaz8-fTR9t-6qMYpc-qdUwnH-ydnXyu-q15epa-ds1msD-oZdtqJ-fHzntE-6oJiR3-aR57P6-4yU71p-gEF3MR-7drYdS-AAL1N1-ADWprh

____

_____
_____
___
____
____